I graduated from college in 1992. A year later, I followed a guy and his family to Indiana. During the 9 months I lived there, I got my first job “in my field”, using the Psychology degree I had just earned, bought my first car, broke up with my “fiance”, got my first very own apartment, and came out, at least to myself. When I moved home in the summer of 1994, I moved back in to my parents home, despite my father insisting that “once you move out, you don’t move back!” I didn’t have any friends at home, so when I ran into Joelle at the Timon Lawn Fete, it felt like “fate”! I knew she was gay, good gossip travels fast, but very few people knew I was. When she called me the next day, she started the conversation with “I gotta tell you something”. No Jo, I gotta tell YOU something. Once again, and not for the last time, friggin’ Joelle saved my life.
I got a job, and within two months, I rented a room in a three bedroom upper with two (straight) girls. I started coaching little loop football cheerleading and worked four ten-hour days. I hung out with Joelle and read everything I could find in the mid-90’s about being gay. Joelle wanted me to meet her friend Eddie, but I had never had a girlfriend! I was REALLY young and had no idea what “being gay” even meant. She told me that Eddie was “a little older” than me, and when pressed, said she was about 7, or maybe 9, years my senior. (As it turned out, Eddie was 14 years older than I. Joelle paid for that lie!) Joelle tried for months to get me to agree to meet them out at a bar, but I was reluctant. What would we have in common? What would we talk about? Joelle insisted: She liked football, I watched football. She loved movies and considered herself a “buff”, I also loved the movies. Finally Joelle convinced me to meet them at Comptons, a large lesbian bar on the city’s East Side. I was apprehensive to walk into Comptons alone and there were no cell phones for me to call Joelle and tell her I was coming. It was a horrible place to meet someone for the first time. It was also the night after a long day of cheerleading competition and I had to work the next morning, at 9:00 AM, for a 14 hour shift. I was tired. I was half asleep, and the music was loud, so we couldn’t talk or learn anything about each other. I left after a couple of hours, feeling like a huge lesbian failure.
The holidays were upon us and with all the plans and responsibilities, we didn’t get another chance to “hang out” until after the New Year. (Eddie wanted me to come to a New Year’s party they were attending but I didn’t know anyone and thought that New Years was way too much pressure; I declined and went to a party at my sister’s instead. I also called the house of the party that Eddie and Joelle were at, but hung up when someone answered.) So, early in January 1994, Joelle and her girlfriend had some returns to make at the mall, and Eddie and I went along, just for an excuse to hang out together. We were like teenagers in the mall, trying on hats and fur coats, eating gigantic cookies, laughing and showing off for each other, and being so “cool”, smoking as we all strolled, hands stuffed deep in our pockets, scuffing our boots. It was exhilarating to me. I was a LESBIAN! I was with other LESBIANS, walking in the MALL. With a WOMAN, who LIKED ME. I might as well be floating on air.
After the Mall trip, Eddie and I became inseparable. For the first four months, we spent every weekend when I wasn’t working, at a friends, who gave us her full size bed while she slept on her couch. I found my own little one bedroom apartment on Orange Street in Lackawanna, in April, and as soon as I moved in, Eddie did too. Well, she spent a night and never left. We dated for 9 months. In September, after a long weekend at camp, I decided that I needed something more, something different, than what I had with Eddie. I was 25 and she was 39… she was my first girlfriend and I was probably her 20th. I had never experienced the “gay lifestyle”. I wanted to go to bars, follow the band, flirt with women, pick up strangers and take trips. Eddie wanted to order Chinese food and rent movies. She did understand but we connected on a level that made it really hard to separate. We still hung out, we shared all mutual friends, and we liked each other. From September through New Years Eve, we still spent most weekends together, despite my insisting we were no longer together.
After New Years 1996, I told her my resolution was to stop sleeping with her. It felt like we were breaking up all over again. Again, she said she understood, and again, she spent the night and never went home. My Grandmother died in February and Eddie and our friends were there for me. They whisked me away to a motel room for the night before the wakes began, and pretended we were in Florida. We cranked the heat up to 80, drank daiquiris and swam in the pool. (Only a few weeks ago, Barb asked me about that trip “to Florida” and I said, I never went to Florida! But that was how I always described that weekend, the time they “Took me to Florida”.) In March, we went to see the band at a bar for a St Patrick’s Day party. It was the “Ides of March”; I should have known it was going to be one of “those” nights, the ones that you never forget. The air felt staticky. Everyone was “on edge”, testy, anxious. At the bar, I was flirting with another friend, Claude, who began to feed into my mood; she played keep away every time she used my lighter, and made sure to stroke my finger when she did let me have the lighter back, catching my eye with that lingering, smoldering look. You lesbians know exactly what I’m talking about. Four of us went out to Eddie’s Chevy Blazer to smoke a joint and Eddie caught “a look” exchanged between me and Claude, through the rear view. She KNEW at that moment that something was going on. She was mad. She waited until we closed down the bar and got back to my apartment, alone, when she laid into me. I wouldn’t sleep with HER, but she was absolutely positive I was sleeping with Claude (for the record, I wasn’t). We fought, argued, threw things. I tried to call someone, she ripped my phone from the jack. I tried to leave, she grabbed at my leather bomber jacket, tearing the pocket. (Hey, it was the 90’s!) I insisted she get out, of course she refused. Where was she supposed to go at 4:30 in the morning? Technically, she still LIVED at home with her parents. But her mom chained the door if Eddie wasn’t going to be home, and I knew she would never frighten her mom by trying to get in at that hour. So I said, again, that I would leave. I ran down stairs and got in my car. Eddie came to the window to tell me it was ridiculous, of course I shouldn’t leave my own house, SHE would go. I didn’t trust her, I was still drunk, and stoned, and just wanted it all to be over. I put my car in drive as she pounded on my window, and as I moved forward, she was gone. I felt my car roll over something and then I heard her screaming. I didn’t know what had happened, and couldn’t hear what she was trying to say. Honestly, I think I had stopped listening. I put the car in reverse; what I didn’t know was that I had run over her ankle, and then ran over it again! I got out of the car and she was lying on the ground. I didn’t even believe I ran her over. How the hell did she get on the ground anyway? I screamed at her, GET UP! I thought she was being dramatic, manipulating me. Somehow, we managed to get her up and on the tailgate of her truck. I went back in the house and called my sister, told her what was going on, and that I was taking Eddie to the ER. I had no idea what was going to happen, but I had to do SOMETHING. I wasn’t even mad anymore, and I got sober pretty fast too.
We drove to Mercy Hospital and sat together at the ER in silence until my sister showed up. She had no idea what had happened, I tried to explain the best I could but I could tell she was not impressed with our drunken escapade. Eddie needed emergency surgery on her ankle, and they put several pins in to keep her foot together. The worst part of it all was that she had an old foot injury from a botched surgery about 20 years earlier. Because of litigation, she waited more than a decade to have her foot fixed and had only been up to par for about a year before I ran her over. Yeah, same ankle.
When she was released from the hospital, our mutual friend Roach (the same one who gave us her bed) decreed that we were not to see each other for a while. Eddie, who could barely walk, stayed with Roach, who “took care” of her. But Roach was more Nurse Ratchet and soon Eddie was calling me for reprieve. We weren’t supposed to have any contact, per Generalissimo Roach, but there was no way we couldn’t. As soon as Roach went to work, we’d be on the phone.
I remember the first time she called after it all blew over. We sobbed. “I’m so sorry!” I cried. “No! I’M so sorry!” she cried. “I should have went home”, she said, “I should have just left!” “Can you please forgive me?” I bawled. “Yes, can you please forgive me?!”
After that, while she healed, we would spend Thursdays with Joelle and her girlfriend, having pizza. There were phone calls to insurance companies, and “stories” to get straight. (Again, thanks Roach!) One day, she called me from her moms. It was a day where she had actually stayed home with her parents. She told me she got a letter from an attorney, who wanted her to SUE me. She flat out refused as we tried to figure out how this lawyer got all her info. “There is no way I’m gonna sue you Hannon.” (She always, only, ever called me Hannon.) Eventually we determined our “friend” Roach had contacted the lawyer, a friend of her father. She never admitted it to me but her excuse was, as always, “try to get whatever you can”. It was all unnecessary because the insurance company took care of her and I was never penalized anyway.
My no fault car insurance would pay for her surgery and a decent settlement for her afterwards. She got a new truck, but I didn’t realize until I was told years later, after she died, that the insurance money paid for her cabin too. She and I carefully planned every inch of that cabin and I never knew it was me who helped make that dream a reality. Even the years we spent hanging out there, all the drama we experienced there…its poetic that she got that getaway on account of me running her over with my car.